The Shift to Interest-Based Discovery: Updating Your Social Playbook

Social media has changed more in the last two years than it did in the previous ten. The way platforms distribute content, the type of content people consume, and how brands succeed have all shifted. If your social strategy still looks like it did in 2019, you’re missing major opportunities.

From Network-Based to Interest-Based Discovery

In the “old” social media era, success was about building followers and getting them to like, comment, and share. Your audience saw content from accounts they followed, and high-production static posts dominated.

Today, platforms prioritize interest-based discovery — serving content based on what people watch and engage with, not just who they follow. This shift means:

  • Watch time and discovery are the new success metrics.

  • Authentic, vertical video is more powerful than polished, static posts.

  • Content can reach far beyond your followers if it’s valuable and engaging.

Then vs. Now: The Social Shift

Then: Post a polished photo of your product, write a clever caption, and wait for your followers to like and share. If you wanted more reach, you boosted the post.

Now: Post a quick, vertical video showing the product in action, layer in trending audio, and focus on keeping viewers watching to the end. The algorithm will push it to people interested in that topic — even if they’ve never heard of your brand.

The New Formula: Educate, Entertain, Inspire

Winning on social now means providing value. People stop scrolling when content:

  • Educates — shares useful tips or insights

  • Entertains — makes them smile, laugh, or feel something

  • Inspires emotion — connects with them on a deeper level

Use Organic as Your Testing Ground

Organic social is the perfect low-risk place to test creative ideas, messaging, and content formats. Post consistently, track performance, and use what works to:

  • Inform your future organic content

  • Turn top-performing posts into paid ads

  • Guide messaging for larger campaigns

This “test, learn, iterate” loop ensures your paid efforts are backed by proven winners.

Why Content Series Are the Future

One of the most effective ways to win on social right now is to think in series, not one-off posts. When you create a recurring format—whether it’s a weekly behind-the-scenes, quick product tips, or customer spotlights—your audience knows what to expect and starts looking forward to the next installment.

The best part? Content series can be incredibly efficient to produce.

Spend a day or two with a well-planned shot list and you could capture enough footage to fuel months of posts. Each piece of content becomes part of a bigger story, building both anticipation and loyalty over time.

Match Content to How People Actually Engage

According to Instagram’s own leadership, users spend the most time in:

  • DMs — where relationships deepen

  • Stories — best for selling and driving traffic

  • Reels — ideal for awareness and growth

  • Feed posts — lowest priority for engagement

Brands can lean into this by entertaining in the feed and Reels, then using Stories for direct calls-to-action.

Video Is Non-Negotiable

Video should make up the majority of your content — aim for 80% video, 20% static. Even when you don’t have video, post a static image as a Reel with trending audio to take advantage of algorithm reach.

The Bottom Line

If your social strategy hasn’t evolved to meet today’s algorithms and user behavior, you’re working harder for less impact. Focus on:

  • Short-form, vertical video that’s authentic and interest-driven

  • Testing and refining ideas organically before investing in paid

  • Creating content series that your audience looks forward to

  • Prioritizing platforms and formats where your audience actually spends time

  • Providing value in every post — educate, entertain, and inspire

Social media is no longer about shouting the loudest to your followers — it’s about consistently showing up with content people want to watch, share, and act on.

Ready to rethink your social strategy? Let’s build a plan that meets today’s algorithms, connects with your audience, and actually drives results. Contact us to get started!